The Demo Worked. Now Test It on Your Files.
November 10, 2026 · Alex Weeks · AI & Automation, Title Industry
The AI demo is the easiest file your vendor will examine all year. The documents arrive in order, the scan is legible, and the answer lands before anyone has time to ask whether the release belonged to that mortgage. I build title software, and I understand why demos work that way. You have twenty minutes to explain a product. But an independent title company should buy on the afternoon after the demo, when the software meets a file nobody chose for it.
October’s posts covered the difference between OCR and extraction, and why the largest model is not automatically the best fit for a title task. The purchasing question comes next: what evidence would convince you this system improves your operation?
Define the Job Before the Test
“Try the AI” is too broad to produce an answer you can buy on. Choose the task you are evaluating. Extracting index fields, summarizing recorded instruments, and drafting a report are different jobs with different failure conditions. A good summary cannot compensate for a missed instrument, and perfect extraction of the documents supplied says nothing about whether the search found the right documents.
Write down what the system receives, what it is expected to produce, and what your examiner remains responsible for checking. Agree on which errors would prevent acceptance before you see the results. Otherwise a fast output has a way of persuading everyone to renegotiate what “good” meant.
Give It Work You Recognize
Start with a manageable sample of completed files selected by your team. Fifty might be enough for an initial operational screen; it is not enough to establish a rare-event safety rate. Include ordinary work in roughly the mix you actually receive, then add a separate group of difficult cases: degraded scans, multiple parcels, similar names, partial releases, and instruments that required real interpretation.
Keep those groups separate in the results. The ordinary sample helps estimate routine effort. The difficult set tests known weaknesses. Mixing them into one accuracy percentage makes the number difficult to interpret in either direction.
Use files your agency has permission to share, through the approved processing path. A pilot should follow the same data-handling expectations you would apply in production. “It was only a test” does not explain why an entire closing file went to an unapproved service.
Review the Answer You Are Scoring Against
A completed file is a useful starting point, not an infallible answer key. Have a qualified reviewer confirm the expected findings for the task being tested. Where experienced examiners disagree, preserve the disagreement and its resolution rather than counting the software wrong for choosing the other plausible interpretation.
Keep some reviewed files out of the vendor’s tuning work. Let the vendor fix problems on the development examples, then run the remaining files without advance coaching. Otherwise you are measuring how well the system learned the test packet instead of how well it handles the next packet.
Count the Minutes After the Output Arrives
Measure review and correction, not just generation. In a hypothetical comparison, a draft that arrives in two minutes and takes thirty-five minutes to inspect and repair has not beaten a twenty-five-minute manual workflow. It has moved the work to a less photogenic part of the process.
Include the time spent finding source references, checking omissions, correcting names, and moving the finished work into your production system. Record retries and files the product declines. Compare against a reasonable baseline using similar work; where possible, use separate reviewers so remembering the file does not make the second method look artificially fast.
Look at the slow files individually. A median improvement can coexist with a handful of files that become substantially harder to finish. Those files tell you where the product needs an escalation path, narrower scope, or more development before you depend on it.
Give Errors Different Weights
A formatting correction and a missed open mortgage should not contribute equally to a score. Keep a record of findings that were omitted, findings asserted without support, and routine edits. Count the cases where the software appropriately said it could not resolve something. An honest escalation is work to budget for; a confident unsupported conclusion is a different problem.
The outcome can be a limited adoption. A product might earn a place on routine instruments while remaining unsuitable for a more complex class of work. That is useful evidence, provided the boundary is visible and the system can enforce it.
Apply the Test to Us
Ask Electra the same questions. I would rather discuss a pilot with a defined task and a reviewed sample than promise an accuracy number detached from the files you handle. Scribe and Autopilot address different parts of the workflow; the evaluation should reflect the job you actually intend to buy.
The demo earns the next conversation. Your own files should decide what happens after it.
Discuss an evaluation of Electra’s title AI on your workflow →
